Bohnanza has become a game-night favorite for the people we
play games with, but the game is very different depending on the
people. I guess that's true for any game, but it can make
Bohnanza especially fun or especially lame.
When everyone at the table is willing to make trades and willing
to give a little extra in one trade and then adjust later by taking a
little more, it really makes the game great. People who are
simply unwilling to trade unless the swap is dead even are going
to make this game painful.
My wife and I have played this game with four different groups of
people. Two of the groups were a blast where everyone was
trading and keeping the game moving and still trying to win. Two
of the groups were slow and calculated and made for a dull
game. What I find interesting is that those players who won't
trade unless it is totally even always end up losing because they
never get the right cards... they won't pull the trigger on a lot of
trades and that is costly. Players who trade freely (and smartly)
will win or be in the running at the end.
My wife and I have also played the 2-player version of the game
and it is fun, although very different from the regular game.
There are definitely more fun 2-player games out there, but
Bohnanza is good enough for a change of pace for two.
If you read most reviews and ratings for this game, they are very
good and that is not a coincidence. This game is very fun and
interesting. It does require players who are willing to trade
though... it just doesn't work that well with people who need
every trade to be dead even. Enjoy!