This expansion is very well worth the money in my opinion.
I actually
bought the
original game
with some
expansions
included (some sort of deluxe package deal). So in order
for me to gauge the value of this
expansion, I had to look back and picture the game without the
expansion :)
One of the cool things about most of the Carcassonne
expansions is
that you can simply throw the pieces into the mix and NOT
follow the
new rules if you want. For example, in this expansion you
can simply
have more players, make the scoring easier (with the
addition of the
point tiles), have more meeples to place (just use the big
guy to keep
score) and have a longer game (with the addition of more
land tiles.)
In fact, when I introduce people to Carcassonne we just
play with the
original rules and I don't have to pick out all the
expansion pieces.
Having said that, the new rules do add a lot to the game.
It can get
a little cut throat, since screwing up an opponent's city
hurts them a
lot more if it has a cathedral in it. The large meeples
also add a
new dimension of decision-making and strategy without
complecating the
mechanics of the game.
I have multiple expansions, and actually just ordered
another off of
this site (I should get it tomorrow - Yay!), but I would say
this is
the best one. If you are ready to freshen things up with
Carcassonne,
this is the way to go. As I said, even IF you don't care
for the new
rules (which I doubt would happen) then at least you have a
bigger game!
Since I can't think of a single complaint about this
expansion, I give
it a good, solid 5 star rating.
In other words... if you are considering it, buy it now.
You won't be
sorry! :)