This is the third game that Martin has done for Winsome and the first
thing to be made clear is that it is not number three in the Ferrocarriles
Pampas/Veld Spoorweg series. Like the others, it is a map and crayons
job, but that is as far as the resemblance goes: new game, new system.
The map shows the towns of Lancashire, together with a couple of overseas
dependencies in the form of Stockport and Scotland. (Yorkshire is tactfully
ignored.) Each town is represented by a dot and there are dotted lines
joining the towns in places where the railway lines will be built. With
the exception of a couple of small junctions, which are there for reasons
of play balance, each town also has a box which is used both as a source
of and destination for passengers and freight. The basic idea is that you
will bid for stretches of line, colour them in to indicate ownership and
then ship things round the network to build up your business. The more
your lines get used, by you and others, the more your income will rise.
The game is driven by two decks of cards. The first deck names the various
stretches of line and determines what is be offered for auction; the second
names towns and generates passengers and freight. A number (equal to one
less than the number of players) is drawn from each deck each turn.
The main parts of the turn sequence go like this:
- Acquire Bank Loans. Railway lines are going to be offered for sale
later in the turn. They will be sold by auction and without money in front
of you, you are not going to be able to compete. However, the interest rate
is a swingeing 20% per turn and so this is your first hard decision. You
already know which lines are going to be auctioned this turn. How much do
you want them and is the debt you will be taking on worth it in both the
short and long term?
- Service and pay off loans. In that order!
- Generate Traffic. This is where you draw cards from the second deck.
Each names two towns and a token, in one of four colours, drawn at random
from a pile of "commodity chips", is placed in each. These tokens are
then there ready to be shipped to one of the towns that accepts that
particular type of traffic. For example, holiday makers head for the coastal
towns such as Southport and Blackpool, while external traffic needs to be
delivered to Scotland or to one of the towns on the southern or eastern edges.
- Draw cards from the lines deck to find out which lines will be auctioned
off next turn. So this is information you have before you spend your
money this turn. As such, it gives you your next tricky decision. Do you go
for one of this turn's offers or will you build up your cash ready for the one
you really want, which is due up next.
- Auction off the lines that were revealed last turn. A player may buy
at most one line per turn and that means that again you will have to decide
what is most important to you and how much competition you are likely to have
to face in order to get it. It also means that you have to go carefully when
you start driving up the bidding in order to keep the other guy honest.
- Build Lines. Each line bought carries a number in the range 5 to 10.
This represents both its value in the final reckoning and how hard it is to
build. Roll two dice: if you match or exceed the rating, you build the lines
you bought this turn immediately; if you fail, you can either stump up extra
cash and build now or wait a turn and build for free. Another place where you
have a real decision to take and it will often be a close one.
- Ship Traffic. Tokens transported can each go along at most five stretches
of line and must finish their journey when they reach a town that accepts that
particular type of traffic. For each stretch of line they go along, they add
one to the owner's income. And this is a permanent addition: it represents
the generating of business, not just a one-off payment. Each player is
entitled to transport one token if they bought a line this time and two if
they didn't. This "bonus token" is something else you need to bear in mind
when bidding for lines, because the extra income that it generates can be
very significant.
- Market Downturn: Depending on the result of a dice roll that applies to
everybody, some of your "income per turn" is lost. The loss represents
customers who have gone out of business or switched to other carriers and it
works (roughly) on a percentage basis. The rationale, to be fully realistic,
ought to allow for business to grow as well as to shrink, but simulating
reality is not the real reason for the rule. Its function is to keep the
leader in check by hitting him harder than the people at the back and as such
it works very well, keeping the game open until very near the end and ensuring
that the two options of borrowing in order to expand early and going more
slowly in order to avoid big interest payments are in balance as strategies.
- Collect your income and then start a new turn.
I have gone through all that in some detail partly in order to give you a
feel for how the game plays, but also to show that, while this is a very
simple game to learn, it is not a simple game to get right. There are lots
of decisions to be taken and they aren't always easy ones. This is a real
game. It is also a very well constructed one in ways that don't become
fully apparent until after you have lost a couple of times. I have already
mentioned the effect of the "market downturn" rule. A lot of work must
have gone into getting that right, but they have got it right. It keeps
the game in balance and hits the leader just the right amount to keep things
interesting. The way that 'traffic carried' turns into income is also
cunning, because over the piece it rewards the player who has built up the
network with the best links: the boost to your income when you can do a long
run almost entirely on your own lines is very significant. Paul Heald was
in the game I played in at Essen, he had played the game at an early stage
of its design and was very impressed with the improvements that Martin and
the Winsome team had introduced in the polishing and development stage.
Congratulations all round are in order. Martin thinks that this is the best
of the three games he has done for Winsome and I agree. I'd have hated it
if he had got a game about my home patch wrong, but he hasn't. Quite the
reverse. Recommended unless you are seriously allergic to train games.